
Your Lawsuit May Have Multiple Other Defendants

Certainly, injury lawsuits (and other civil claims) involving multiple defendants can quickly become complicated, particularly when it comes to co-defendant insolvency and allocation of liability.
If you have been sued by a plaintiff in a case in which there are multiple defendants, you may be wondering how the existence of co-defendants will affect your strategy and overall liability. For a clearer understanding of how to proceed, it’s important that you consult with a skilled North Carolina civil litigation defense attorney who has experience handling claims in which there are several co-defendants.
So, how does North Carolina law address the issue of multiple defendants? The laws are actually quite straightforward, but we’ll use some examples to help contextualize its application in the real world.
Joint and Several Liability
North Carolina applies the doctrine of joint and several liability, which puts a rather large burden on the defendant(s). Under joint and several liability, each and every defendant involved in a civil lawsuit — no matter their actual fault — is liable for the entire amount of damages. If the defendant pays above their “pro rata” share (given their actual fault), then North Carolina law allows the defendant to file suit against their co-defendants and recover the excess that they paid.
Sounds complicated, right? Don’t worry — let’s shine a light on all this legalese with a brief and simple example.
Suppose that you are being sued in a motor vehicle accident case in which there was a multiple car pileup. You are one of two co-defendants. The plaintiff is asserting total damages of $250,000. Regardless of how much at fault you and the co-defendant are separately for the plaintiff’s injuries, the plaintiff may recover fully from either of you. For example, if you are financially insolvent and lack adequate insurance coverage, the plaintiff may choose to recover the $250,000 in its entirety from your co-defendant, who may have adequate insurance coverage to pay out the damages.
Contribution
North Carolina law does give each defendant the option of filing suit against their co-defendants and seeking “contribution” for the excess damages they paid. How does it work? Let’s return to the previous example.
Suppose that the court found that between you and the one other co-defendant in the motor vehicle accident, you were each 50% at-fault for the accident. Now, suppose that the plaintiff recovered fully against you. In essence, you paid 100% of the damages ($250,000). In North Carolina, the law of contribution would allow you to file suit against your co-defendant and recover the excess damages (you were technically liable for only $125,000, but paid twice that amount) that you paid. As such, you could force your co-defendant to pay the remaining $125,000 as contribution.
Despite the fact that contribution is available, the fact that defendants in North Carolina have to seek contribution puts a rather large and unfair burden on defendants. Further, it can be frustrating to recover when your co-defendant is insolvent.
·
0



